Thanksgiving Catering Menu NYC: A Thoughtful Feast Without the Fuss

Thanksgiving in New York is a time of gratitude—but between cooking timelines and crowded kitchens, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. At Green Apple Catering and Events, we believe the holiday should be filled with warmth, flavor, and connection—not fatigue. That’s why our Thanksgiving catering menu NYC is crafted to bring you a complete, fully prepared feast without the stress.

From elegant apartment dinners to corporate Friendsgiving lunches, we serve meals that honor tradition with a fresh, modern touch. Our team handles everything from sides to sauces to seasonal desserts—so you can gather around the table, not the stovetop.

Sample Thanksgiving Catering Menu

Classic Turkey Selections

• Roasted Whole Turkey: Served with your choice of two sides, one stuffing, one salad, gravy, cookies or seasonal pie
• Carved Roasted Turkey Breast: Includes two sides, one stuffing, one salad, gravy, dessert
• Asian Turkey: Glazed with ginger soy, honey lemongrass and hoisin
• Maple Roasted Turkey: Naturally sweet with a bourbon butter glaze
• Herb Brined Turkey: Slow roasted with sage, rosemary, and citrus zest

Succulent Entrées

• Prime Rib: Slow roasted and served with natural jus
• Tenderloin of Beef: Accompanied by béarnaise sauce
• Grilled Herbed Atlantic Salmon: Served with horseradish sauce
• Grilled Portabella Mushroom Napoleon (Vegetarian): Roasted vegetables, spinach, and chevre stacked and drizzled with balsamic

Stuffings & Dressings

• Classic Thanksgiving Dressing with Parsley, Sage, and Thyme
• Apple and Sausage Stuffing
• Brioche Stuffing with Dried Fruits and Fresh Sage
• Wild Rice, Dried Cherry, and Almond Stuffing
• Pumpkin and Rice Stuffing

Savory Hot Sides

• Old-Fashioned Mashed Potatoes
• Scalloped Yams with Praline Topping
• Roasted Winter Vegetables with Lemon Balsamic Vinaigrette
• Brussels Sprouts and Chestnuts, Italian Style
• Garlic Rosemary Roasted Potatoes

Seasonal Salads

• Arugula Salad with Oranges, Pomegranate, Avocado, and Goat Cheese
• Roasted Beet, Endive, and Blue Cheese Salad with Walnuts
• House Salad with Mesclun Greens, Dried Cranberries, Candied Walnuts, and Anjou Pears

Desserts & Baked Sweets

• Apple, Pear & Cranberry Cobbler
• Southern-Style Pumpkin Pie
• Holiday Mini Butter Cookies
• Pumpkin Pudding
• Apple Crumb Pie

Festive Beverages

• Hot Mulled Cider with Cinnamon Sticks
• Classic Eggnog with Fresh Grated Nutmeg

Clean Comfort Rooted in Holiday Tradition

Thanksgiving is about more than food—it’s about heritage, comfort, and warmth. Our menu reflects those values through roasted entrées, hearty sides, and seasonal desserts that feel indulgent without being overly rich. We’ve updated the classics for modern eaters—offering vegetarian mains, gluten-free stuffings, and homemade sauces that cater to a variety of dietary preferences.

Whether you're planning a candlelit dinner or a large office potluck, our food arrives beautifully presented and ready to serve. It’s the same blend of warmth and elegance we bring to seasonal menus like our Easter Sunday catering menu NYC, where every bite tells a story of care and celebration.

Thanksgiving Catering for Every Type of Gathering

From brownstone kitchens to downtown boardrooms, our Thanksgiving menu fits any format. We offer everything from buffet trays to individually boxed meals, allowing flexibility for family events, nonprofit celebrations, or company-wide gratitude luncheons. Our team manages labeling, delivery timing, and portion planning—so the only thing you need to do is gather your group.

Like our Passover catering menu NYC, this Thanksgiving offering is built around tradition, taste, and inclusivity.

Diet-Friendly Options Without Compromise

No one should feel left out during the holidays. That’s why we offer thoughtful entrées like our Grilled Portabella Napoleon and Wild Mushroom Stuffing for plant-based guests, or sweet potato sides without added dairy for those with sensitivities. Every item is labeled and curated with balance in mind, so dietary needs never mean less flavor.

This same mindset guides our offerings in the St. Patrick’s Day catering menu NYC, where hearty meals still meet the needs of modern eaters.

Easy Ordering and Holiday Simplicity

The holidays are packed enough without extra planning stress. Whether you want to build your own meal or choose a preset package, we help streamline the process. From delivery logistics to seasonal presentation, our staff ensures everything arrives on time, beautifully packed, and ready for serving.

Clients looking for well-managed, large-scale service appreciate the consistency we deliver in all formats—just like in our Good Friday catering menu NYC, where seamless execution and mindful cuisine work hand in hand.

End the Celebration with Seasonal Sweetness

A Thanksgiving table isn’t complete without a warm dessert. Our selection of pies, puddings, and cobblers brings autumn flavors to life in every bite. Add a cider bar or fresh eggnog to finish the meal on a cozy, communal note. For additional ideas on dessert displays or drink pairings, check our Christmas catering menu, where festive concepts inspire gatherings all season long.

Reach out today to book your Thanksgiving catering in NYC—and enjoy a holiday filled with connection, gratitude, and incredible food.