Halloween Catering in NYC: Bold Menus for Spooky, Sophisticated Events

Halloween has grown far beyond trick-or-treating—it's now one of the most anticipated social events of the fall season. In New York City, Halloween gatherings range from office costume parties to private cocktail soirées and themed client events. What ties them all together? Food that’s creative, memorable, and perfectly seasonal. Halloween catering brings a thrilling edge to your event while ensuring you don’t have to lift a finger. With NY Green Apple’s elevated Halloween catering services, your spooky spread can be as impressive as your décor.

Why Halloween Is Perfect for Themed Catering

This holiday offers a unique opportunity to play with presentation. You can take timeless fall ingredients and dress them up with eerie elegance or playful creativity. The best Halloween catering isn’t just about serving great food—it’s about creating an atmosphere that’s immersive and unexpected.

Think passed hors d’oeuvres styled like witch’s bites, color-themed buffet stations, and desserts that look like edible art. Whether you’re planning a rooftop masquerade or an in-office lunch, Halloween menus let you go bold—both in flavor and visual storytelling. At NY Green Apple, we specialize in these details, helping companies and hosts turn Halloween into a signature event on their calendar.

Halloween Catering Menu by NY Green Apple

Creative, seasonal catering packages for events across NYC

Hors D’Oeuvres ($44.00 per dozen)

• Monster Eyes: Traditional deviled eggs with fresh herbs
• Avocado Deviled Eggs
• Olive Puffs with Green Olives
• Pumpkin Meatballs: Beef, chicken or turkey meatballs in buffalo sauce with celery sticks
• Bloody Fingers: Chicken strips with marinara dipping sauce
• BBQ Bat Wings: Chicken wings served with ranch dressing
• Mini Tape Worm Sandwiches (hot dogs)
• Cheddar Witches Fingers: Cheese straws with almond fingernails
• Witches Chicken Fingers
• Mini Mummy Pigs in a Blanket
• Mini Meatball Skewers with Masala Sauce
• Mac and Cheese Pops
• Black Bean Roll Ups with sour cream and salsa
• Gourmet Mini Burgers: Sesame bun with tomato, blue cheese and Thousand Island dressing, topped with a cocktail pickle
• Mini Burgers with all the trimmings: onions, lettuce, tomato, pickles, cheese, condiments
• BBQ Pork Mini Sandwiches

Halloween Platters

• Barfing Pumpkin Guacamole with Tortilla Chips – $9.95 per person
• Layered Spider Web Dip – $9.95 per person
• Skeleton Antipasto – $11.95 per person
• Halloween Dessert Platter – $8.95 per person
• 7-Layer Dip – $9.95 per person
• Gourmet Halloween Sugar Cookies – $7.95 per person
• Mini Halloween Cupcakes – $7.50 per person
• Pumpkin Pie (10-inch) – $44.00 per pie
• Sugar-Spiced Almonds – $9.95 per person
• Dirt with Worms: Chocolate pudding topped with Oreo crumbs and gummy worms – $7.95 per person
• Apple Dip with Spooky Crisps – $6.95 per person
• Honey Chip Granola Bars – $5.95 per person
• Three-in-One Popcorn Crunch (peanuts, popcorn, candy corn) – $6.95 per person

Buffet Package ($38.95 per person)

• Rosemary Plum Roast Pork
• Medallion of Chicken Breast with Capers, Mushrooms, and Chardonnay Reduction
• Russian Beef Stroganoff with Wild Mushrooms
• Green Beans with Basil
• Scary Rice with Black Beans and Diced Carrots
• Sweet Potato Casserole with Mushrooms
• Ginger Squash Soup
• Crunchy Apple Salad with Raisins, Celery, and Walnuts
• Cornbread
• Halloween Themed Dessert Platter

Beverages ($6.95 per person)

• Black Halloween Punch
• Spooky Citrus Punch

How to Elevate Your Halloween Event

Catering isn’t just about the menu—it’s about how everything ties together. For Halloween, that could mean table setups inspired by apothecaries, vintage glassware for drinks, or interactive dessert stations styled like mad scientist labs. Themed plating and unexpected details like black napkins, candlelight, and edible flowers make even a workplace lunch feel transformed.

Halloween also allows room for fun guest interactions. Add a photo booth, costume prizes, or trivia to keep the energy up. Our team can work with you to match your food with the tone of the event, whether you're hosting an upscale cocktail hour or a laid-back team celebration.

NY Green Apple: Your Partner in Seasonal Event Catering

Our Halloween catering packages are designed to scale. Whether you're serving 10 or 200, each dish is prepared fresh, delivered on time, and styled to fit your theme. From delivery and setup to eco-conscious packaging and allergen labeling, we handle every detail so you can focus on hosting.

If you’ve worked with us for other seasonal occasions—such as Valentine’s Day or Cinco de Mayo—you know our menus combine creativity with consistency. That same care goes into our Halloween offerings.

Book Early for the Best Selection

Halloween is one of our busiest catering dates, so we recommend reserving your menu 10–14 days in advance. Whether you want a single buffet drop-off or a full-service event with themed staff and stations, NY Green Apple can bring your vision to life.

And if you're already planning fall events beyond Halloween, check out our fall-focused Administrative Day catering for professional yet festive workplace options.

Let us help you treat your guests—and give them something truly delicious to remember.